0 items in Cart
Blue Agave Mexican Restaurant Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Social
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Social
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Blue Agave Mexican Restaurant Online Ordering Menu

9745 Johnstown Rd
New Albany, OH 43054
(614) 855-9060
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
91% of 414 customers recommended
Start your carryout order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

LUNCH SPECIALS

*Available from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.* All dishes served with two sides.
18. Taco Salad 
Crispy flour tortilla shell with chicken or beef, mixed salad, tomatoes, cheese, and sour cream. Does not include side order.
$9.99
23. Quesadilla Rellena 
Grilled flour tortilla spread with fried beans and cheese and stuffed with beef tips or chicken. Served with your choice of two sides.
$8.99
25. Chimichanga 
One soft or fried flour tortilla filled with beef tips or tinga chicken. Served with two sides.
$8.99
26. Speedy Gonzales 
One taco, one enchilada, and two sides.
$9.29
27. Pollo Marinado 
Grilled marinated chicken breast with grilled onions, mushrooms, and melted Chihuahua cheese on top. Your choice of two sides and three flour tortillas.
$11.99
28. Beef or Chicken Burrito with Cheese Dip 
Served with two sides.
$9.99
30. Burrito Simón 
Pork burrito filled with pork barbecue with Mexican sausage, black beans, and green sauce topped with salsa verde. Served with two sides.
$11.57
31. Enchiladas Verdes 
Two chicken enchiladas with fresh green tomatillo sauce on top. Served with two sides.
$8.97
89. Enchiladas Divorciadas 
Two enchiladas (chicken or beef) one covered with green sauce and one covered with red sauce, served with your choice of two sides.
$9.29
34. Lunch Fajitas Express 
Chicken or beef (sirloin steak) fajitas served with two sides, fresh guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo, and three flour tortillas.
$11.49+
35. Flautas 
One beef and chicken flauta served with two sides, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and sour cream.
$8.99
36. Carnitas Express 
Pork tips and your choice of two sides and three flour tortillas.
$11.49
37. Huevos con Chorizo 
Scrambled eggs with Mexican pork sausage. Served with two sides and three flour tortillas.
$9.49
32. Mole Poblano 
Shredded chicken with mole salsa served with two sides and three flour tortillas.
$9.57
38. Fajita Burrito 
One burrito filled with chicken or beef (sirloins teak), fajita, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and tomatoes. Covered with cheese dip. Served with two sides.
$10.39+

APPETIZERS

Add mixed salad (romaine lettuce, red cabbage, and carrots), tomatoes, and sour cream for $1.55.
2. Nachos with Carnitas, Ground Beef, Chicken, or Beans 
$8.99+
3. Chorizo Nachos  
$9.49+
4. Nachos Supremos  
Cheese nachos with chicken, beef, beans, mixed salad (romaine lettuce, red cabbage, and carrots), fresh avocado, and tomatoes.
$11.99+
5. Nacho Fajita 
Cheese nachos with fajita vegetables.
$10.49+
6. Queso Fundido con Chorizo  
Melted Chihuahua cheese with Mexican pork sausage.
$7.99+
7. Spinach Dip  
Nacho cheese with spinach, fresh green onions, and tomato.
$6.59+
8. Bean Dip 
Fried beans topped with cheese dip.
$6.49+
9. Cheese Dip  
$3.49+
10. Fresh Guacamole Dip  
$3.39+
11. Queso Fundido con Camarón 
Grilled shrimp, onions, mushrooms, and poblano peppers with melted Chihuahua and American white cheese.
$11.79+
12. Quesadilla Bar 
Two 10" tortillas cut in pieces, filled with cheese, chicken or steak, and served with lettuce, pico de gallo, guacamole, and sour cream on the side.
$15.49+
15. Ceviche  
Tilapia fish cooked in lime juice, mixed with onions, tomatoes, cilantro, and serrano peppers.
$10.49+

SOUPS & SALADS

17. Blue Agave Salad  
Bed of mixed salad with pineapple tomato, fresh avocado, and your choice of dressing.
$13.29+
16. Sopa de Pollo  
Shredded chicken, broth, fresh avocado, pico de gallo, and tortilla strips.
$4.49+
18. Taco Salad 
Crispy flour tortilla shell with chicken or beef, mixed salad, tomatoes, cheese, and sour cream.
$10.49
19. Black Bean Side Salad  
Mixed salad, black beans, fresh avocado, tortilla strips, and your choice of dressing.
$4.49
59. Cabrito Monterrey 
Goat meat cooked with special Monterrey sauce and served with rice, fried beans or black beans, pico de gallo, and flour tortillas.
$18.79+

CREATE YOUR OWN COMBINATION DINNER

All combination dinners come with your choice of two sides: rice, beans, mashed potatoes, black beans, mixed salad, or steamed vegetables.
One Item 
Choice of burrito, chalupa, enchilada, chile relleno, taco, beef or bean tostada or tamale. Tacos, burritos and enchiladas are normally made with ground beef, chicken or cheese. The chicken is already cooked with onions, tomatoes, bell peppers and spices. You may substitute a hard shell taco for a soft shell taco for an additional 59¢. Potatoes cooked with onions, tomatoes and cheese. Chile rellenos are breaded and made with mozzarella cheese or mashed potatoes.
$9.99+
Two Items 
Choice of burrito, chalupa, enchilada, chile relleno, taco, beef or bean tostada or tamale. Tacos, burritos and enchiladas are normally made with ground beef, chicken or cheese. The chicken is already cooked with onions, tomatoes, bell peppers and spices. You may substitute a hard shell taco for a soft shell taco for an additional 59¢. Potatoes cooked with onions, tomatoes and cheese. Chile rellenos are breaded and made with mozzarella cheese or mashed potatoes.
$11.59+
Three Items 
Choice of burrito, chalupa, enchilada, chile relleno, taco, beef or bean tostada or tamale. Tacos, burritos and enchiladas are normally made with ground beef, chicken or cheese. The chicken is already cooked with onions, tomatoes, bell peppers and spices. You may substitute a hard shell taco for a soft shell taco for an additional 59¢. Potatoes cooked with onions, tomatoes and cheese. Chile rellenos are breaded and made with mozzarella cheese or mashed potatoes.
$13.09+

BLUE AGAVE TACOS

Three tacos per order. Choose same protein (from more than 12 proteins) with homemade corn tortillas, flour tortillas, or lettuce wraps. Served with lime, radish, and salsa with one side. Choose either Mexican or American style (Mexican = onion & cilantro; American = cheese, lettuce, tomato & sour cream). Choose your salsa ($1.00 each): Pineapple with Mango Salsa (chopped tomato, onion, cilantro, mango, and pineapple), Salsa Taquera (roasted tomatillo, tomato, habanero, chile de arbo, and spices), Cebolla Pibil (red onions and habanero cooked with lime juice and seasoned with oregano & spices), Diabla (red tomato, chile de arbol, a little bit of sugar boiled in water), or Chipotle Ranch (the flavor of ranch and chipotle mixed together).
Rib Eye Steak Tacos 
Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
House Made Chorizo Tacos 
Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Birria de Res Tacos 
Small brisket cooked with Guajillo pepper & spices. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Pastor Tacos 
Pork marinated with vinegar, pineapple, and red peppers. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Fish Tacos 
Grilled tilapia. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Grilled Shrimp Tacos 
Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Brisket Tacos 
Cooked with Mexican spices. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Carnitas Tacos 
Pork leg cooked in oil seasoned with Mexican spices. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Chicken Tinga Tacos 
Cooked with onion, chipotle, and different spices. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Cochinita Pibil Tacos 
Pork cushion marinated for 24 hours with banana leaves with our famous Grandma's recipe. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Marinated Chicken Tacos 
Chicken marinated for 24 hours with chile Guajillo, ancho, and seasoned with our secret recipe. Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Grilled Mushroom Tacos 
Three tacos per order.
$15.99+
Zucchini & Corn Tacos 
Three tacos per order.
$15.99+

FAJITAS

All fajitas are served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, mixed salad (Romaine lettuce, red cabbage and carrots), fresh guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo and three flour tortillas. All fajitas are cooked with tomatoes, onions, bell peppers and mushrooms.
Chicken Fajitas 
$16.79+
Sirloin Steak Fajitas 
$17.99+
Shrimp Fajitas 
$20.99+
Fajitas Texanas 
Sirloin steak, chicken, and shrimp.
$18.99+
Fajitas Hawaianas 
Chicken, shrimp, pineapple, and zucchinis.
$19.99+
52. Carnitas Locas  
Skillet with grilled bell pepper, tomato, mushrooms, onions, zucchini, and roast pork. Served with your choice of two sides and flour tortillas.
$16.99
99. Chiapas  
Chile poblano stuffed with sirloin steak, grilled mushrooms, bacon, tomatoes, zucchinis, and squash. Covered with melted Chihuahua cheese and own sauce on top. Served in a sizzling skillet, with rice and beans, mixed lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, and tomatoes
$15.99

SPECIALTIES

30. Burrito Simón  
Pork burrito filled with pork barbecue with Mexican sausage, black beans, and green sauce and topped with salsa verde. Served with two sides.
$12.49
40. Quesadilla Mexicana  
Grilled flour tortilla spread with fried beans and cheese. Stuffed with beef tips or chicken and served with fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and sour cream.
$9.99
42. Enchiladas Supreme  
Supreme combination of one chicken enchilada, one bean enchilada, one cheese enchilada, and one beef enchilada topped with ranchero sauce, mixed salad, and sour cream.
$11.49
43. Burritos Deluxe  
Two burritos - one chicken and fried beans and one ground beef and fried beans - topped with mixed salad, tomatoes, mild red sauce, and sour cream.
$11.49
44. Burrito California  
Extra-large burrito filled with Mexican rice, fried beans, and chicken or steak (sirloin steak), covered with cheese dip. Served with mixed salsa, tomatoes, fresh guacamole, pico de gallo, and sour cream.
$11.49+
46. Fajita Quesadilla  
A grilled flour tortilla spread with cheese and chicken or beef fajita, tomatoes, onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms. Served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and sour cream.
$15.99+
41. Carnitas Michoacanas  
Pork tips served with Mexican rice, fried beans, or black beans, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, pico de gallo, and three flour tortillas.
$15.69
100. El Volcán  
Grilled shrimp, sirloin steak, and Mexican sausage cooked with onion, mushrooms, bell peppers, tomatoes, and special red sauce. Served with rice and fried or black beans, mixed salad, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo, and three flour tortillas.
$18.99
47. Enchiladas Bandera  
One chicken enchilada with green sauce on top, one cheese enchilada cheese dip on top, and one beef enchilada with red sauce on top. Sour cream on top. Served with rice, mixed salad, fresh avocado, and tomato.
$12.49
48. Chimichangas Suprema  
Two soft or fried flour tortillas stuffed with beef tips or chicken. Topped with cheese, mixed salad (romaine lettuce, red cabbage, and carrots), pico de gallo, sour cream, and fresh guacamole. Served with Mexican rice and fried beans or black beans.
$14.19
49. Iguana  
Grilled sirloins teak and chicken breast wrapped in a spinach tortilla, topped with cheese dip. Served with black beans, mixed salad, tomato, fresh guacamole, and sour cream.
$16.69
50. Burritos Locos  
Two burritos filled with shredded pork cooked with sundry chile red sauce, covered with sour cream, and topped with mixed salad fresh avocado and tomatoes.
$11.29
53. Chimichanga Grande  
Shrimp, chicken, sirloin steak, chorizo, bell peppers, onions, tomato, and mushrooms. Fried cheese dip on top. Served with rice, beans, mixed salad, guacamole, sour cream, and pico de gallo.
$17.49
Burritos Mojados 
Two burritos (chicken or beef) covered in cheese dip and topped with your choice of green or red salsa, served with rice and beans.
$12.49
Cochinita Pibil 
Marinated baked pork Yucatan style. Served with three flour tortillas, rice, and beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo, and tomato. Side of red onions and orange habanero cooked in lime juice.
$14.49
Tostada Pibil 
Marinated baked pork Yucatan style tostada spread with refried beans, topped with fresh shredded lettuce, sour cream, cottage cheese, and a side of red onions with orange habanero cooked in lime juice.
$7.99

CHICKEN

Mixed salad (romaine lettuce, red cabbage, and carrots). Substitution of flour tortilla to spinach tortilla, 39 cents extra.
76. Pancho Special  
Grilled chicken strips, melted cheese, Mexican pork sausage, and pineapple. Served over a flour tortilla with Mexican rice, mixed salad, sour cream, tomatoes, and cheese.
$13.99+
77. Pollo Chihuahua  
Grilled chicken breast with grilled onions, poblano peppers, mushrooms, and melted Chihuahua cheese. Served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, and flour tortillas.
$13.99+
65. Pollo Chipotle  
Chicken strips cooked with special chipotle sauce and served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, and three flour tortillas.
$13.99+
66. Chilaquiles Mexicanos  
Corn tortillas cooked with chicken and our own special mild red sauce. Topped with melted cheese and served with Mexican rice, fresh guacamole, mixed salad.
$11.49
67. Pollo a la Diabla  
Chicken strips cooked with special very hot sauce and served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, and three flour tortillas.
$13.99+
68. Arroz con Pollo  
Grilled chicken strips served on a bed of rice with cheese dip on top. Garnished with cilantro and side salad with your choice of dressing.
$13.99
70. Mole Poblano  
Shredded chicken topped with mole sauce and served with Mexican rice, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and three flour tortillas.
$11.49+
72. Chori Pollo  
Grilled chicken strips topped with Mexican pork sausage and cheese. Served with Mexican rice, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and three flour tortillas.
$13.99+
73. Jose Special  
Grilled chicken strips and vegetables over a bed of Mexican rice. Covered with melted cheese and served with fresh guacamole, mixed salad, sour cream, and flour tortillas.
$13.99+
74. Blue Agave Bowl  
Grilled chicken strips sautéed with zucchinis and squash, red & green bell peppers, with creamy red sauce over a bed of Mexican rice or black beans.
$13.99
69. Pollo Loco  
8 oz. grilled chicken breast served with enchilada sauce and cheese sauce on top served with rice, beans, mixed lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, and pico de gallo.
$13.99
75. Pollo Marinado  
Grilled chicken breast marinated and grilled with onions, mushrooms, and melted Chihuahua cheese. Served with Mexican rice, mixed salad, sour cream, and three flour tortillas.
$13.99+
29. Pollo Sriracha  
Signature dish. Two grilled chicken fillets seasoned with sriracha and topped with bacon bits, pineapple, cheese dip, and garnished with parsley. Served with Mexican rice, refried beans, and three flour tortillas.
$13.99+
Enchiladas Doña Maria 
Three chicken enchiladas covered with mole poblano sauce and cheese. Served with your choice of two sides.
$11.99

STEAK

Substitution of flour tortilla to spinach tortilla, 39 cents extra.
61. Steak Tabasqueño  
Grilled 10 oz. rib-eye steak and four shrimp wrapped with bacon topped with melted cheese and served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, and three flour tortillas.
$21.99+
55. Carne Asada  
Grilled sirloin steak served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, pico de gallo, and three flour tortillas.
$17.39+
56. Burrito de Barbacoa  
Burrito filled with shredded beef barbacoa, Mexican rice, fried beans with cheese dip, mixed salad, pico de gallo, and fresh guacamole.
$11.49
57. Steak Ranchero  
Grilled 10 oz. rib-eye steak with ranchero sauce. Served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, pico de gallo, and three flour tortillas.
$17.39+
58. Steak Tampico Special  
Grilled 10 oz. rib-eye steak cooked with bacon, poblano peppers, and mushrooms. Topped with melted Chihuahua cheese. Served with fried beans black beans, rice, and flour tortillas.
$17.79+
59. Cabrito Monterrey 
Goat meat cooked with special Monterrey sauce and served with rice, fried beans or black beans, pico de gallo, and flour tortillas.
$18.79+

SEAFOOD

Mixed salad (romaine lettuce, red cabbage, and carrots). Substitution of flour tortilla to spinach tortilla, 39 cents extra.
92. Fajita Quesadilla Camarón  
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, 14 grilled shrimp, bell peppers, onions, tomatoes, and mushrooms. Served with Mexican rice, fried beans or black beans, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, tomatoes, and sour cream.
$16.99+
91. Camarones al Mojo de Ajo  
14 grilled marinated shrimp sautéed with garlic and served with Mexican rice, mixed salad, tomatoes, and sour cream.
$16.99
45. Camarones Rellenos 
Seven stuffed shrimp with poblano pepper and Chihuahua cheese, wrapped with bacon. Served on a bed of salad, rice, and black beans.
$16.49
96. Tilapia Cancún  
Grilled tilapia fish wrapped in banana leaf served with Mexican rice, tomatoes, mixed salad, fresh guacamole, pico de gallo, lime, and three flour tortillas.
$14.99
97. Camarones con Piña  
14 grilled shrimp with pineapple cheese dip on top. Served with rice, mixed salad, fresh avocado, sliced tomato, and sour cream.
$16.99
95. Camarones Endiablados  
14 grilled shrimp cooked with very, very hot sauce and served with Mexican rice, mixed salad, tomatoes, and fresh guacamole.
$16.99
Cazuela Tropical 
Grilled shrimp, zucchinis, squash, mushrooms, tomato, and cheese sauce on top.
$17.69
Relleno Cancun 
Roasted poblano peppers stuffed with crabmeat imitation, cheese, shrimp, and fresh tomato. Served with your choice of two sides.
$14.19
Shrimp Cocktail  
14 shrimp, chopped cilantro, onions, tomatoes, and avocado served in its own juice with lime, special red sauce, and crackers. Served hot or cold.
$17.39

VEGETARIAN

51. Vegetarian Chimichanga 
One deep-fried burrito stuffed with grilled green peppers, zucchini, and fresh avocado covered with cheese sauce. Served with Mexican rice, black beans or refried beans, gourmet greens, coleslaw, and sour cream.
$11.19
84. Vegetarian Enchiladas  
Three cheese enchiladas with onions, bell peppers, tomatoes, squash, and zucchini. Served with Mexican rice and tossed salad.
$11.99
80. One Bean Burrito, One Cheese Enchilada & Mexican Rice 
$10.19
81. Vegetarian Fajitas  
A light combination of fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, zucchini, squash, and tomatoes served with Mexican rice, mixed salad, fried beans or black beans, and pico de gallo with three flour tortillas.
$13.49+
83. Spinach Quesadilla  
Quesadilla stuffed with cheese, spinach, onions, and tomatoes. Served with Mexican rice, mixed salad, tomatoes, pico de gallo, and sour cream.
$11.39
85. Quesadilla Vegetariana  
A grilled flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, tomato, zucchini, and squash. Served with Mexican rice and mixed salad.
$11.39
86. Vegetarian Burrito Grande  
One burrito filled with mushrooms, zucchini, squash, onions, and tomatoes. Covered with cheese dip and served with Mexican rice, fresh guacamole, mixed salad, and sour cream.
$11.99
88. Fresh Avocado Burrito  
A large spinach flour tortilla filled with fresh avocado, grilled zucchini, chopped spinach, poblano peppers, cheese dip, and poblano sauce. Topped with cheese, avocado, and poblano sauce. Served with mixed salad.
$12.49

KIDS

For children under 12 years old. All kid's meals include a side and a kid's soft drink.
101. Mini Corn Dogs (6) 
$6.29
102. Hamburger 
$6.29
103. Kid's Pizza 
$6.29
107. Chicken Fingers 
$6.29
108. Macaroni & Cheese 
$6.29
109. Quesadillas 
Two grilled flour tortillas with chicken or ground beef and mozzarella cheese.
$6.29
110. Taco 
$6.29
111. Enchilada 
$6.29

A LA CARTE

114. Beef Tips or Chicken Chimichanga  
$5.29+
115. Corn or Flour Tortillas  
Limit of 3 orders.
$1.97+
116. Beef, Chicken, or Mushroom Quesadilla 
$4.49+
117. Cheese Quesadilla  
$2.99+
118. Chicken Tamale  
$2.99+
119. Beef, Chicken, or Bean Taco  
$2.79+
120. Beef or Chicken Soft Taco  
$3.89+
121. Beef, Cheese, Chicken, Bean, Spinach, Mushroom, or Mashed Potatoes Enchilada 
$2.99+
123. Beef, Chicken, Bean, or Mashed Potatoes Burrito 
$4.89+
125. Chile Relleno  
$3.39+
126. French Fries  
$2.49
129. Chicken, Beef, or Bean Tostada  
$4.99+
130. Fried Beans or Cup of Black Beans  
$2.59
131. Mexican Rice  
$2.59
132. Mashed Potatoes  
$2.59
Jalapeños  
$1.09
Shredded Cheese  
$1.39
Sour Cream  
$1.09
Pico de Gallo  
$1.39
Chiles Toreados 
Grilled fresh jalapeños and onions.
$1.99
Side Salad 
$3.00
Fresh Avocado 
$3.50
Grilled Veggies 
$3.50
Grilled Steak 
$7.99
Grilled Chicken 
$6.99
Homemade Salsa (5.5oz) 
$0.99

DESSERTS

Churros 
Sweet strip of fried dough dusted with sugar and cinnamon, filled with Mexican caramel, covered in chocolate syrup and whipped cream.
$4.79
Flan 
Mexican custard.
$3.89
Postre Familiar  
One flan, one sopapilla, and one xangos served with your choice of strawberry syrup, chocolate, or honey and whipped cream.
$9.99
Xangos Cheesecake 
Creamy cheesecake wrapped in pastry tortilla fried golden dusted with cinnamon and sugar.
$4.99
Sopapilla 
Fried flour tortilla with honey, butter, and cinnamon.
$3.49
ChocoFlan 
A slice of chocolate cake topped with a slice of Mexican custard.
$5.99
Fried Ice Cream 
Ice cream rolled in special flour mix with cinnamon and chocolate wafers. Served with your choice of strawberries, chocolate, or honey and whipped cream.
$4.49

SOFT DRINKS

Soft Drink 
Coke, Diet Coke, Fanta Orange, Sprite, root beer, or ginger ale.
$2.69
Iced Tea 
$2.69
Lemonade 
$2.69
Coffee 
$2.69
Hot Tea 
$2.69
White Milk 
$2.79
Chocolate Milk 
$2.79
Cranberry Juice 
$2.79
Orange Juice 
$2.79
Pineapple Juice 
$2.79
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook Visit our TripAdvisor Visit our Yelp
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.